The film has all the standard elements of Shakespeare’s Othello, the Snow Bunny, the Hater and the Moor. It takes place in the 1990s. Instead of General of an Army, the Moor is Captain of the High School basketball team. During a high school basketball game, Odin James (Phifer) scores the basket that wins the game for his team. Later at an awards ceremony, the coach, Duke Goulding (Martin Sheen) presents the MVP award to Odin for his efforts, an award he shares with his teammate Michael Cassio (Andrew Keegan).
In giving Odin the award, Duke passes over his son Hugo (Hartnett), Odin’s teammate and best friend. At a party celebrating the victory, Hugo plans with school outcast Roger Calhoun (Elden Henson) to go to the school’s dean, Bob Brable (John Heard) and tell him that Odin raped his daughter, Desi (Stiles), whom Odin has been dating. Hugo promises Roger that Desi will be his after Odin is out of the way, but Roger is only a pawn in Hugo’s ultimate plan to destroy Odin.